See all
262 photos

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

(Now Closed)

BBQ Joint and Sports Bar$$$$

Upper West Side, New York

Save

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

63 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

lauren uJune 3, 2015
this place is the best!!! the meat is great but omg the sides !!! also love the sauces they keep on the table--fun to try! My favorite since I was really young
Carlos BidoJuly 1, 2012
Very big mouse runs through the back counter at the bar. Our group points it out to the bar tender. His reaction: what do you want, it's new york city. Aaaahhh how authentic.
Nelson VegaJanuary 18, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Sometimes I can't understand the bartenders attitude. Friday after 4pm is a nice happy hour but sometime looks like she hate that we drink too fast.
Randal KennedyJuly 25, 2014
The BBQ wings hit the spot. Don't forget to come here for half priced apps for happy hour.
nisha roxanneOctober 9, 2010
the fish ball for 19.00 dollars gets u twisted if shared with 3 people..lmao..the watermellon bomb!! is 90 dollars for maybe 11 people and you are drunk on the floor!!! great deal
Paul KatcherOctober 1, 2011
Been here 25+ times
New menu item Press'd Bourbon BBQ Brisket sandwich is awesome! If you like their other brisket meals, give this one a try
Bachelor10April 6, 2011
Saddle up to the bar and make friendly with the short-skirted waitresses and they’ll take good care of you; generally better than at most places. Read more
Rey MedinaJune 22, 2012
Get the swamp water! Huge fishbowl you can share with your friends. Def worth the money.
Amanda TheilerFebruary 27, 2015
Monday-Friday Happy Hour From 4-8pm 1/2 off Apps, Saturday 35 Cent Wings From 12PM - 4PM
Scott JacobsOctober 16, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Megan on thursdays and sunday nights is the only way to go.By fay the best bartender in NYC.
Allie CarieriAugust 17, 2014
Tuesdays are half off apps and beer/well drinks. It's the best deal
Daniel WMarch 24, 2015
Walked in here in the middle of the day and there were 10 children running around the bar screaming.
Jaycee QueenAugust 21, 2011
Sweet tea is amazing!!! Taste like a mixture of honey and deliciousness! Yummmy!
Brandon CarderApril 18, 2010
Southern Ribs with Chipotle BBQ sauce. Good stuff. The only BBQ I've eaten in NYC, and it's pretty damn good. Read more
Raj S.November 17, 2010
$2.50 PBRs on Tuesday. Karaoke on Tuesdays as well, plus plenty of TVs to watch the game.
Morgan AveryJune 20, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Don't come on Thursday evenings the live music is annoying to listen to.
Nikkia AbSeptember 10, 2011
Always go for Hot wings on Saturday's between 12-4. They're only 35 cents!
Nick HuddlestonNovember 1, 2012
$2 beer Happy Hour (5-7) + half-off appetizers = a good time.
Jonathan WatsonFebruary 21, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Happy Hour beers between 4pm and 7pm at the bar. Great Bartenders and staff. Half Price appetizers.
JenniferOctober 6, 2011
Been here 50+ times
Come when Amy's here. Her bangs are super sexy and you know you can't resist!
Daniel CaneloApril 6, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Blackened Chicken is the must go good for dinner
Thomas PhilipApril 21, 2013
Swamp Water Fish Bowl definite party starter!
DejaJanuary 8, 2012
Order the wings ! & swampwater you will be good to go :)
Jessica RubinSeptember 3, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Daniella is the best bartender. No question.
Marques StewartFebruary 19, 2012
It's a bit on the cramped size. When you order, ask how long it will take to get your order.
Brian McGMay 5, 2015
Delicious BJ's Signature BBQ burger
Spain SpainNovember 13, 2010
Don't get the brisket sandwich - they're stingy with it. Get a burger or pulled pork sandwich instead.
Donna NixFebruary 22, 2013
Ask for Ashley! The best service ever!!!
JacobMarch 7, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Southern appreciation night on Wednesdays.
RENZO Spirit BuffaloApril 6, 2014
Been here 5+ times
it's all about the sauce..
Chris PorowskiMay 31, 2010
I order the brisket came out wit old bread and meet was to dry to eat kind of tastless also, drinks yes $3 but there is no alkohol in it, and by the way it's take forever to get your food.
Allan FFebruary 20, 2010
This is a great place for happy hour. I promise you, you can't beat the price!
Mediha KosovrastiApril 5, 2010
don't try and sit outdoors if you're just planning on drinking and people watching. We were told that we were not able to sit there once we'd already ordered our sangria pitcher
DejaJanuary 8, 2012
Order the wigs the are delicious hhj
Megan BiglinMay 17, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Amy is the best! By far!
RyanApril 11, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Try the fish bowl. Full of vodka and big enough for a group!
Mel GibbsonMay 14, 2013
Make sure to check your order before you leave... Or you'll be waiting over an hour for them to correct their mistake!
The Corcoran GroupMay 21, 2010
Some of the best mac & cheese in the city!
Gabor BarnaSeptember 20, 2011
try the daily all you can eat deals
Jason SchwarzMay 26, 2009
Get a swamp bowl, and don't forget to try all the various hot sauces, especially the chipotle.
Richard La FranceSeptember 8, 2011
Been here 50+ times
The pressed Bourbon BBQ brisket is AMAZING!!!
Hector Bustillos MadridAugust 7, 2014
OMFG awesome ribs
Judah RichardsonNovember 19, 2012
Decent place. I think. If only I remembered being here
TMO Loves FootballMarch 10, 2012
Best mac n cheese EVER! And $3.75 Natty Light :-)
AprilOctober 17, 2011
This is the worst Brother Jimmys I've ever been too. The service was terrible. Had 2 get my own water, had 2 search 4 the waiter on three separate occasions to take orders. #EPICFAIL
Sean McKenzieDecember 10, 2011
The service here is historically horrible. The waitresses take so long for everything, water-downed drinks. Brother Jimmy's is no brother of mine. More like a bitchy aunt.
Megan JohnsonSeptember 8, 2013
Really good wings
Jon DubeJune 19, 2011
Come on Sundays for All You Can Eat Ribs!
Craig ThompsonMarch 24, 2012
Try the Beef Brisket Sandwich
brigitte gOctober 11, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Andrew, the best bartender. Period.

1 2

262 Photos

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Appears on 93 lists

More from Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Is this your business? Claim it now.