See all
7,806 photos

Eataly Flatiron

Gourmet Store and Italian Restaurant

NoMad, New York

Save

Eataly Flatiron

9.1^/10

9,909

ratings

Ranked #5 for wine in New York
Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and Food Network
"year-round rooftop beer garden with hearty bites from Mario Batali"(23 Tips)
"The prime rib sandwiches are delicious, the rooftop bar is fun."(36 Tips)
"So crowded, but worth it for the Italian meats and fresh pastas."(23 Tips)
"Best gelato in NYC - the pistachio is really addicting!"(113 Tips)

1,245 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Italian food
gelato
wine
coffee
mario batali
rooftop
espresso
sandwiches
prime rib sandwich
paninis
ice cream
pastries
cheese
bakeries
sorbet
Nutella
meats
breakfast food
lunch
gourmet shops
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Nicole Alexandra GóesJune 23, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Make sure to check out their new rooftop restaurant, Sabbia. Opened only 2 months ago, the Italian Riviera-themed decor features cabanas, palm trees, vintage posters and a boat-shaped oyster bar.
Upvoted 3 hours ago
Anne BrooksApril 25, 2017
Fantastic beer garden on the roof during summer. Also the vegetarian restaurant is quite good even if you aren't veggie / vegan. If you're lucky you might see some celebs or Mario Batali
The Most Interesting Man in the WorldJune 17, 2014
I enjoy this place almost as much as two other nationally-themed locations. ‘Swedenim’ – a Scandinavian jeans outlet. And ‘Fondubai’ – a fondue restaurant with a twist of the Middle East.
Upvoted Jan 26
Svetlana NovokshonovaSeptember 4, 2014
Whenever you are there must visit Eataly for lunch or just Italian proviant shopping, but be ready for crowds of people there. It really feels like you are in Campo do Fiory, or other Italian market.
David BlackmanNovember 30, 2015
eataly is an imported italian grocery store, co-owned by mario batali, that is a PALACE of food - there are multiple little restaurants within it, a beer garden on the roof, and it's really beautiful
Bruce HaydonJanuary 7, 2017
This place is a near-perfect Italian gastronomical experience in the form of an indoor Italian street market. Gelato stand, wine bar, and pasta restaurant all serve up topnotch food. Don't miss this!
EaterAugust 4, 2016
High up on the roof of the Eataly complex is an Italian version of a beer garden, with a retractable glass roof that opens to cooling night breezes. Read more
AlAnoud A AlGhunaimMarch 15, 2022
Huge upscale market with fresh fruits and vegetables. Pantry items from Italy and on-site baked bread, focaccia, and plenty of Italian restaurants. Once you’re in it’s really hard to get out lol👌🏻
nymagDecember 26, 2010
Italian wonders about here, but don’t miss the perfectly al dente cacio e pepe at La Pizza and La Pasta. Featured in Where to Eat 2011! Read more
Gilt CityJune 28, 2011
What a playground of fabulous Italian food. Where to even begin? Our suggestion is walk around, sniffing and sampling from all the different stations. Then go for it and indulge in something decadent.
Diego RomeroJanuary 25, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Dive into Italy's flavors and aroma. Check the 400+ cheese selection and choose between The five options: birreria, veggies, seafood, pasta & pizza and meat specialties. Tip: Reserve & be on time.
Ale TowerJuly 10, 2016
The food at the various mini restaurants is really good and you can buy great quality ingredients you won't find elsewhere (but if you can do, as it's way pricey). Oh, and best gelato I've had in NYC.
Jess HannOctober 17, 2014
Been here 10+ times
The Eataly brand products are actually a great deal here. I picked up some 14 month aged Eataly prosciutto for dinner the other night and my bf and I thought it was the real deal - for $15/LB less!
Melissa ChaiAugust 11, 2017
Their hazelnut gelato is really good but I keep coming back for their mango sorbet... best I've ever had
Paula FreireDecember 25, 2014
It's a place where you can spend a whole day. Everything is delicious and you can bring the ingredients home after this happy day. Try the Classic Tiramisu on the Dessert place. It's to die for!
Celeste NorthJune 22, 2014
Unfortunately you can't order from all the tables but be sure, whatever you choose will be amazing. Try the specials of the day and if you have some space for dessert check out the Nutella bar!
Cheen The CuriousAugust 10, 2022
Find the Eataly kiosk in front the Flatiron Plaza, & next to the park. Under the same umbrella as nearby Eataly & Il Patio. Limited menu of pizza, drinks & beverages, ice-cream & granitas
Adam McCueAugust 22, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Get to the focaccia counter for reasonably priced, gigantic snacks. Just a couple dollars and gigantic. Also pretty fast moving since nobody knows about it.
Rob FitzhenryNovember 20, 2016
Everything. walk around and take in all the amazing food before making your decision. The chocolate alone can take a while... They have Venchi...an Italian chocolate that is so oo good
Fabian MartinJanuary 5, 2022
Very delicious pizza slices. Can’t sit down however if you take it from the slice shop. I recommend the Quattro Formaggi with Truffle
Carly HeitlingerFebruary 11, 2015
Obsessed with the pizza and pasta section at Eataly. Put your name on the list and while you're waiting for a table explore the whole location! There's so much to see and taste!
Cezar LenciOctober 20, 2014
I guess everything is great. The restaurants are really good. I had the Piatto Misto Di Salumi & Formaggi at La Piaza and a Capricciosa pizza at La Pizza & La Pasta, both fantastic!
Ms HeleneJanuary 14, 2018
Il Pesce counter for salted cod risotto with caviar $28 and grilled blue fish with quinoa and roasted vegetable salad $24.
Michael CNovember 18, 2019
Totally off the hook. Make your way through the packed people to all of the individual areas. Pasta, bread, cheese, gelato, Italian snacks... go crazy!
Gary HorNovember 21, 2015
Get the focaccia for lunch. The grilled eggplant is my favourite. If you want dessert, the gelato is a safe bet. A trip to NYC would be incomplete without a stop at Eataly, especially for foodies.
Julie SosciaAugust 1, 2018
Stop by the rooftop or Nutella bar, the rooftop is great with seasonal pop-up restaurants and cocktails year round. The Nutella bar speaks for itself!
Jason KeathJuly 15, 2021
Eat at the pasta bar, “Il Pastaio” and order Malloreddus. They are baby gnocchi and amazing. Pair with some Chianti Classico and relax away the afternoon.
Veronica VMay 2, 2013
The best restaurant in Manhattan! Good prices, friendly staff, delicious food, and the best thing is that you can buy any ingredience they have used for cooking your meal. Simply awesome!
DaveApril 15, 2015
Super weird, but you can't take food from one of the mini restaurants and eat it in one of the other mini restaurants. So figure out where and what you would most like to eat.
TingJuly 21, 2015
This place is like an Italian foodie's dream comes true. It has absolutely everything 'made in Italy' and more. Not to be missed when in Flatiron district.
DoubleDeuceNovember 28, 2023
The bathrooms here are solid for a weary traveler. The takeaway desserts and pre-made items are a steal. The happy hour deals at each restaurant are as good of a deal as you can find in NYC.
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍December 21, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Eataly as a brand isn't merely a restaurant, it's an experience! This Flatiron location is my favorite in town. Although a bit touristy therefore, crowded but definitely that's part of its charm
Julia BirnbachMay 9, 2017
This is one of my all-time favorite places. Make sure you buy produce in the market- the prices are very reasonable and the quality is fantastic!
Guha ArunkumarJune 10, 2017
Start with the pumpkin ravioli with pistachios at the back, and make your way to the entrance to pick up some Tiramisu (HEAVENLY) and coffee. 😍
The Wall Street JournalSeptember 20, 2010
Among the gastronomic greatest hits worth checking out here: handmade mozzarella, oysters, veal and lamb stuffed ravioli, and gelato. And lots and lots of wine. Read more
JessicaAugust 6, 2015
I love this place!! Having been to the original Eataly in Italy, it was like being transported back to Rome for a few hours. Though much more crowded, I couldn't stop looking at everything
Miche ZenMay 4, 2019
The rooftop at the flatiron location was beautiful, lively .. the cocktails and appetizers delicious
Yousif DMay 31, 2016
Grab a bite in the la pizza & la pasta! Waiting time can be long!! But the freshness of the food and authenticity worth the wait.
Caroline DengDecember 26, 2015
Free wifi and a good study spot for those who like white noise. They have basically everything—coffee, an espresso bar, authentic Italian gelato, a cheese shop, deli, restaurant, and more!
Jeffrey GlueckMay 7, 2022
Been here 5+ times
Need reservations for the roof garden but worth it on a nice day. The egg and prosciutto sandwich place hidden in the middle of the store is a secret gem though, for takeout.
Serious EatsJuly 19, 2013
Mega Italian market with multiple restaurants, butcher, seafood, and cheese counters, bakeries, gelato, coffee, pizza, sandwiches, and more. Great but expensive selection; gets crowded.
Amy CoatesJuly 3, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Pistachio gelato all the way. It's unbelievable. Best flavour at Eataly and maybe the best gelato in the world... Sorry Italy, this is legit.
Kimberly SmileyApril 3, 2014
The best pizza & pasta I've ever had. Had I known how much we'd love it, we'd have planned our trip around daily visits to Eataly. Get there at opening so you can get a table without a long wait.
Thais MarconAugust 12, 2013
This place is awesome!! Several restaurants for all sorts of food, pasta, vegetarian, fish, nice selection of Dogfish Head beers and food. Very nice birreria on the roof. Definitely a fav spot in NYC!
CharlottesApril 7, 2015
Wow, it's wonderland for foodies! I thoroughly enjoyed perusing the shelves and bought some lovely oil and vinegar. Must return to sample the many in house dining options. All looks divine.
FunesFebruary 21, 2015
Great place to browse all kinds of delicious fare. Stop by for panini or any of the 4 restaurants. Don't forget the birreria on the roof or the Nutella bakery on the side.
Andres ElizondoApril 2, 2019
It’s like they took a chunk of an Italian market and shoved it in a store. Come here for any Italian need you have. Fresh pasta bar, meat and cheese market, and wine selection are covered here
PeopleOctober 12, 2010
With 50,000 square feet of delicious Italian treats, you're bound to spot a star—we bumped into Jimmy Fallon! Tip: Relax with a brew in the sprawling rooftop beer garden before loading up groceries.
summer daidoneMarch 29, 2015
Absolutely amazing experience! Tried gelato, espresso, wine, and chocolates.. All were so authentic and delicious. A feast for the all of the senses.
Spotted by Locals - city guides by localsOctober 1, 2013
From the bakery to the homemade pasta bar, over to the cheeses, to the butcher and coffee bar, your heart will be more than content with the offering of all this first rate Italian food Read more

1 2 3 4 5 6...25

7,806 Photos

Eataly Flatiron

Related Searches

Places inside Eataly Flatiron

You might also like

Places people like to go after Eataly Flatiron

Appears on 7,069 lists

Top places in the area

Other Eataly locations

Is this your business? Claim it now.