Momofuku Milk Bar
(Now Closed)Dessert Shop, Bakery, and Coffee Shop$$$$
Theater District, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and New York Post
275 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Wejdan โจApril 24, 2017First timers, get their best sellers bundle (soft serve, b'day truffles, crack pie and compost cookie). You basically get the cookie for free, but you got to try some amazing stuff!
Hans HauptJuly 1, 2013The Cereal Milk Ice-Cream/Milkshake is fantastic. Get this if you are visiting for your first time. It tastes like the milk in a bowl after eating the cornflakes. Ask for a sample if you're unsure.
Jonathan LSeptember 11, 2017Get the soft serve twist. They have a standard couple of cakes in stock here at all times. The rest have to be pre-ordered. Tip: Buy a cake truffle beforehand to get an idea of the cake flavors.
Julie SosciaSeptember 5, 2018Everyone should try the corn cookies, those are THE best..but really any of the cookies and the crack pies are a good snack. Coffee is decent. The cereal ice cream is addictive.
Cassie VargaJuly 11, 2016Compost cookie is awesome! Cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie is great too;Cereal milk soft serve with cornflake topping, is very yummy ๐ also birthday cake shake is awesome!
SaraOctober 25, 2014The crack pie really is good. The blueberry and cream cookie deserves more hype. Sample the cereal milk soft serve & get a coffee to take the edge off the sugar you just consumed.
Going to a party? Bring a box of individually wrapped cookies, a cake, or a crack pie to make everyone happy. If just dropping in, get some cereal milk soft serve and a cookie. Lots of butter = love.
Elynn LeeJanuary 11, 2016Big location. If you're looking to buy a lot of Milk Bar cookies, definitely check this place out. They also have small boxes for packing. Highly recommend the corn, compost, and chocolate cookies.
Zayed KhanSeptember 16, 2016The coke float flavoured soft serve tastes exactly how you'd expect. Pretty cool, good enough to warrant trying at least once, but not good enough to want an entire single serving of most of the time.
HessaSeptember 6, 2016Good soft serve ice cream ( with cornflakes topping) for the cake loved the salted pretzel cake. Good thing that they close late!
- Hans HauptJuly 1, 2013I tasted The Crack Pie, Dream Girl Pie & Candy Bar Pie. Crack Pie has a wonderful & subtle caramel taste (best one IMO). Dream Girl is healthier & crispy. Candy Bar tastes like a giant Reese's Piece.
MattJuly 21, 2016Thr Crack pie was delicious, surprisingly not too overly sweet. It was very thick, $5.50 a slice.
Christina ChinJune 20, 2016Got fruity/cereal milk softserve..taste like fruit loops! Super creamy which I like. Cornflake topping is a must try. But it's not cheap, $6 for it
Danyel SmithMarch 21, 2015tried the fried chicken skin with the caviar-dusted ranch dressing dip. i want to say it was icky. it was in fact precisely what chips and dip should be, always and forever, in every way.
Lauren VallsOctober 8, 2016Cereal milk soft serve with corn flakes- so good! And all the other cookies, truffles and pies are unique and good too. If you like desserts, it's hard to go wrong here.
JosephineJune 26, 2018After watching Netflix Chefโs table I had to try out the Milk bar. My favourite - The birthday milkshake! To die for!
Rita ChengDecember 5, 2016super empty nowadays because of the tower. Don't be fooled by the barricades-- they're still open. All the cookies are really good, and cereal milk is nostalgic and great.
summer daidoneApril 3, 2015The soft serve cereal milk is amazing.. Worth the trip. Get it with the corn flake topping! The atmosphere was cute and cozy.
Midtown respite, good for locals and tourists looking for sweets and icy treats, especially during the summer months. Always get crushed cereal on the corn milk soft serve.
MeliApril 21, 2013Highly recommend their crack pie & chocolate malt balls--yum! Have it with a glass of milk. not the best dessert place but not the worst. Lounge area upstairs is amazing! Best part about this place.
Burger DaysOctober 20, 2014You can't go wrong with ANY of the cookies here but our favorites were the Three C's: Corn, Compost and Confetti.
Varun ShettyAugust 23, 2014Grab one of these boxes and fill it up Supermarket Sweep style. Cookies: compost, confetti. Birthday cake truffles. Slice of crack pie. Glorious.
Harumi UOctober 16, 2014They have a package deal of 4 most popular items. If you can't decide what to eat try this! (Crack pie, compost cookie, cereal milk and birthday cake)
huge fan of the cereal milk soft serve (sans corn flakes). and you cant go wrong with the corn flake choco chip marshmallow cookie!- Julie SosciaJanuary 27, 2019Easy to miss from the outside, so keep an eye out! You must try the crack pie and the cereal milk soft serve. Coffee is decent.
Gulrays JamieFebruary 2, 2014Grab a crack pie (lovely for those with a sweet tooth) an sit in the comfy hotel attached's seating areas :)
Amy N.February 29, 2016chocolate malt cake truffles and compost cookies FTW. Did you know you can find the official recipes online?
Mesh AJanuary 2, 2017Tried the birthday truffles and cracked pie. So yummy and liked the birthday truffles more โค Ice-cream was not served at the time I was there :(
krisha mendozaJune 13, 2012the best cookies are the corn and blueberry. get one of each and if you know me in real life, you better bring some back to LA for me (thanks in advance)!
Alice NamJanuary 12, 2016Such an addictive ice cream place. Sometimes you just want to digress from gelato places and crave soft serves
Nathan KamMay 26, 2012Crack Pie is to die for...literally. A little too sweet for my taste to finish the whole thing, but a fun treat nonetheless. Definitely worth a try!
Ashley ChanJanuary 7, 2017The desserts are underwhelming. The cereal milk ice cream tastes really odd, and the crackpie and birthday cake truffles are so sweet that I felt like I was eating pure butter and sugar mixed together
mike popovicMay 22, 2015Get a snack for yourself and some cookie mix to take home to your family. Then, they have to make you more cookies!
J DruniMay 25, 2014If you want to pay $5 for the experience go ahead and have the cereal milk shake. It's something you can prepare at home any day.- Martin JenningsSeptember 15, 2016Cereal milk is lovely. The best cookie we had was the compost cookie
Try the Oatmeal Stout Soft Serve - With oat crumbs. Excellent new flavor. 1st of 5 stops on all day milk bar tour for the new menu.
MarkSeptember 1, 2014No seats so take your deliciousness into the lobby or mezzanine of Chambers Hotel next door!
Richard DinhAugust 7, 2014Get a free sample of the frozen yogurt. It's good stuff. Some flavors are not that good. Love the cereal milk!
Kevin O'NeillJune 5, 2016O M G cereal soft serve ice cream. Throw all the toppings on it and share with a friend so you can split the gluttony.
ๅฐๅฐJuly 15, 2015Don't try to eat soft serve with your iPhone in hand - the soft serve melts everywhere and drips into all the buttons! Now my buttons are all sticky and no longer satisfyingly clicky ๐ข
Silas MorriseySeptember 29, 2015I don't even remember what it was I orderedโฆ a chocolate shake? It had a nice gooey syrup, but only on the cup, leaving the bulk of the dessert as you'd expect: cold.
Kate AlcongaNovember 19, 2013The outdoor signage is small but the cereal milk jug and cornflake choco chip marshmallow cookie are yummy!
Mike FriedlichFebruary 6, 2017Birthday and Chocolate Malt Cake Truffles are amazing, but the cereal milk soft serve was tasteless to me. I dont see how thats any good.
Anastassia ChepelkevitchFebruary 20, 2011Make sure to get the cornflake crunch on top of the salty pistachio crunch soft serve. Their ice cream is the perfect balance of the sticky goo of the typical soft serve but doesn't melt too quickly.
What's Good HereAugust 9, 2014Everyone who comes here should try this - Cereal milk ice cream with corn flakes topping
Serious EatsJuly 25, 2013Whacky flavors of soft serve, sweet cake balls, and fat, chewy cookies are the hallmarks of this bakery. And a very sweet pie called Crack Pie.
Ryan AmbsJune 22, 2016The cereal milk ice cream is interesting and unique but gets old real fast as its their only type.
736 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
This location is now Closed.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- MonโFri
- 8:00 AMโ11:00 PM
- SatโSun
- 8:00 AMโMidnight
(917) 261-2422
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"Amazing warm cookies for a sweet break. A bit simple but good set of choices"
Arnaud Rรฉautรฉ - 8.5
"Goats milk ice cream WITH toppings and white chocolate raspberry halva are incredible. Love this little place!"
Dolci Key - 8.9
"Awesome french boulangerie some of the best croissants in the whole of NYC"
Paolo Barone
Places people like to go after Momofuku Milk Bar
Appears on 1,028 lists
Created by Len โคโคโค
200 items • 36 followers
Created by Kino
256 items • 37 followers
Created by Raja H
158 items • 67 followers
