See all
984 photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

190 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

AlAnoud A AlGhunaimAugust 24, 2017
Food network fans, this place is for you. The genuine American vibes👌🏻 food was incredible, The pretzel tenders and their ribs! Oh my🙌🏻❤️
Chris BelseyMay 21, 2017
There's only 1 choice here. Mac'n'cheeseburger. It may sound crazy but it really works. If you are Brave enough you can eat by hand but I chickened out and used a fork & knife...
Erin SamuelsenDecember 15, 2013
Great service. The pretzel chicken and Vegas fries were tasty and my general tsos pork shank was fall off the bone amazing. Also, they have a blackberry mojito that I had to have more than one of. Yum
Evan EstolaOctober 17, 2014
It is what you think it is. It is what you want it to be. It is America. It's 11pm and you're in the hell that is times square and there's no wait and pbr tall boys are $6.
Amanda KinseyJuly 31, 2016
Great service. Unlike some restaurants my glass was never empty. The food was fantastic. I got the Volcano Chicken for my entree & I would absolutely recommend it!
Jessica BJanuary 31, 2016
Walked in and was seated right away. Food was excellent & alcohol(cocktails) were great- not watered down . Staff was super friendly & very attentive even when it got busy. I will definitely be back.
M. KhalidJuly 2, 2013
This restaurant is owned by Guy Fieri from the food network. Food is delicious I have been to many American rests this the real American food. An amazing experience I highly recommend it 9/10.
Cynthia HultbergFebruary 13, 2013
Everything was great! Sashimi Tacos were to die for, Blackened Cajun Chicken Alfredo very flavorful and Salted Whiskey Caramel Fool perfect way to finish it off
Deborah B.April 1, 2013
With all the negative reviews - we were a little hesitant but were happily surprised. Bacon Mac and Cheese, Garlic Roasted Chicken were great entrees. Ahi tuna tacos were small and perfect for an app.
Lindsey TimbermanJanuary 6, 2013
Service was outstanding, Travis really took care of us. Pretzel chicken was yummy, bourbon brown sugar wings were tender & flavorful. Nice beer list. Cool decor. Guy was even there during our visit!
Fred GeigerJuly 26, 2013
Not sure why he had bad reviews in the Times, I had great food and drinks there, had a Whiskey Highway and the spicy dirty martini. Started with the calamari which was awesome, had the Dipper.
James CJanuary 18, 2017
Great place to hit if in the city near shows. Got a free drink with app. The food was really good and the drink selection is great.
Natalie MJuly 31, 2015
The Mac & cheese burger and roasted chicken was bomb! BUT the chicken alfredo was actually the best.
Chris Du4February 28, 2014
I ate here just to participate in the tips. It's truly horrendous. I was assaulted by the sounds of Hootie & the Blowfish on entry & treated to splattershits within 1hr of departing. Thanks, Guy!
Mary StankevichSeptember 9, 2014
Great place with friendly staff! Perfect for a casual dinner. Try the garlic roasted chicken! 👍
Michelle MillerApril 6, 2013
Best cheese (provolone) sticks!!! Bacon-wrapped BBQ shrimp is amazing as are the fries and onion rings!!! One of our favorite places to eat in NYC!!!
Little ManFebruary 16, 2013
Simple menu but the pulled pork slyders or the bacon, chicken mac n cheese were great. Good atmosphere & great classic 70s rock tunes. Great service!
Kevin B.June 3, 2016
BBQ/meatloaf was fantastic. Large enough portions that my wife and I shared an appetizer and meal. Excellent service.
M. KhalidJuly 4, 2013
The donkey sauce is not made out of a real donkey. It's mostly mayo mustard and some sauces. 9/10 for Guy's Resturant and a must visit in NYC.
Guy DavisJanuary 9, 2013
Large portions. Good prices considering this fact and the location. Made for tourists but a good lunch spot and I think a tourist would do well here. Tasty food abound!
Sarah LattaDecember 3, 2012
Got the Big Dipper and Italian nachos. Both were amazing. Price seems comparable to most of NYC. Great atmosphere. Excellent attentive wait staff.
ANA tSeptember 8, 2015
wounderful food and staff ..try the mac cheese pasta and the mixed salad ..garlic fries is the best👍🏻
Frani LiebermanMay 14, 2013
I felt closer to my Italian roots after a plate of the guy-talian nachos- complete with pepperoni, guy's Italian sausage and flecks of sweet basil
Edgar EOctober 12, 2015
Bacon Mac n Cheese Burger and California Spring Rolls were awesome! Great house brewed beer also!
Becky BurrJuly 12, 2013
LOVE THIS PLACE! I only wish they had GUINNESS. Waiter said they won't get it because its imported and Guy only gets American beers.
Chris GayomaliSeptember 15, 2012
In the future they'll have tiny paperweight versions of this New York icon next to mini Statue of Liberties. Get the Guy-talian nachos.
Peter YoungMay 10, 2013
The buffalo wings are super spicy. Avoid the grilled tuna unless you really like raw fish. They serve apple cider on tap here, which is a plus.
Angela Le GrandMay 12, 2013
Food was Awesome! Best server ever was Lindsey! Freaking awesome! Thanks for the great suggestions on food and drinks! Listen to her!! Great lady!
Paul Travis KleinFebruary 4, 2015
It's a ridiculous place. Go for the kitsch, but venture no further than the bar. The only safe food are the wings and IPA.
Diane ScottFebruary 24, 2013
Great service, the Vegas Fries and ahi wanton tacos are amazing. House margaritas are good too!
rickricardu Ricardo Jr.January 30, 2016
Foreigning friendly. Nice beers, super big burger with Mac'n'cheese.
Justin OrgelMay 25, 2013
Get the tortilla soup & the $400 bomber jacket. You won't regret it.
Brian JonesJanuary 11, 2014
Been here 5+ times
This place is just awesome. Really good food. Need to try this place out at least once in your life.
Aleksa LCMarch 17, 2013
Had the chili. It was really good. The calamari was also splendid. Nice feel of the environment too
Dirissy DoanNovember 8, 2016
If you like wasabi, you'll love these sashimi tacos!!
Marek MillerApril 28, 2013
Make sure you try the home brewed porter - awesome. And I'm saying it as European.
Luis FSAugust 7, 2014
Have to order the Motley que ribs. Really tasty
Chuck ThomasOctober 20, 2013
Nice rare lamb rib chop...perfect!! That's for you Stephen with a PH!
Thomas LoebigDecember 22, 2012
The Chili was very good. I think the NYT review was way out of line! Try the Sleigh Ale.
Sarah LimJuly 16, 2013
Go big or go home. Kidding. It was a bit under the top; we were expecting the opposite.
Dan NurczykNovember 13, 2012
The Garlic Fries are amazing, and paired with the Pulled Pork Sliders, it was heaven!
K MOctober 9, 2016
Have to confess: didn't try the food. Just drank here while we waited for a table at Carmine's.
Raul LaurelOctober 26, 2012
Get the Watermelon Margarita (but with the jalapeño infused tequila...totally awesome)
Chelsea Mae HassmanMay 1, 2013
NYC law requires calorie counts on the menu. But Guy knows that law doesn't apply to this place, which is located in 'MURICA.
Kara P.December 8, 2012
Line out the door? Ask if there are seats at the bar - you will likely be told yes and sat quickly.
Colleen KJuly 27, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Bacon Mac and Cheese with Chicken! Yum!
Mya WashingtonNovember 9, 2017
Mac and cheese burger.....most amazingly delicious thing on the menu
LaurenOctober 15, 2012
sashimi tacos are tasty and crispy. inside decor was cool and a decent music selection.
Regina LeeJuly 24, 2013
Order two Guy-Italian Nachos, one for you and one for the rest of your friends to share.
Brendan LewisMay 14, 2013
If you're looking to strip paint off metal, I highly recommend ordering a pitcher of sangria in a "to go" tub

1 2 3 4

984 Photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Appears on 88 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.