See all
369 photos

Grimaldi's

Pizzeria$$$$

Flatiron District, New York

Save

Grimaldi's

7.2^/10

423

ratings

Ranked #8 for family-friendly places in the Flatiron District
"No slices, just whole pies and cash only, but worth it."(6 Tips)
"Great pizza, but not much space to enjoy it."(66 Tips)
"It's Famous Grimaldi's sans the line."(2 Tips)
"I get pepperoni and onions on it."(2 Tips)

94 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
whole pies
casual
good for groups
lively
good for dates
great value
good for a quick meal
sausage
pepperoni
cash only
spinach
basil
lunch
dinner
nightclubs
mushrooms
takeout
church
clean
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Jeffrey ZeldmanNovember 24, 2017
Same as the famous Grimaldi’s in DUMBO, but with no lines. Unpretentious coal-fired pizza. Located in former Limelight nightclub (NYC haute spot in 1980s), which, in turn, was formerly a church.
Carrie LawsonJuly 9, 2016
The whole pizza pie, plain large is only $2 more, friendly cooks, open till 11:30 on weekends, remember it's cash only & no slices but the pie is worth it!
macfixerMarch 13, 2017
The pies are made from premium ingredients, and coal-fired. The menu is helpful when explaining how many people each size will feed.
Zlata ZubenkoJuly 9, 2016
Delicious pizza but stay far away from buffalo chicken - the sauce sodium content was so unbearable we had to send it back. In the end we had a "small" pizza with chicken and marinara sauce (feeds 3!)
Erin MurphyOctober 13, 2014
Been here 5+ times
My favorite pizza in Manhattan. The sauce is perfect, the crust isn't too thick, and the cheese is real mozzarella. I get pepperoni and onions on it. There's never any wait for a table either.
Michelle ConnochieFebruary 5, 2018
Nice tasty pizzas. A large was enough for the two of us. Customised half and half which was good. Really tasty and worth a visit
EM!September 30, 2014
You will leave content and FULL! So yummy. Sitting outside was awesome; secluded little area between two old buildings. I felt like I was in Italy
Melanie W.November 23, 2015
Been here 10+ times
This secret location of Grimaldi's is the best. There is never a line, the service is quick, and the pizza is delicious.
Torzin SMay 20, 2015
Its pizza is very nice. The taste of tomato is quite deliciously different. Pepperoni is truly perfect.
Christopher TaiJuly 1, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Go to Grimaldi's if you want a taste of Italy. The tomatoes are imported from Italy, so you can't beat that. As for all the folks who love American pizza, just give this one a try. Everything's fresh
AadityaMarch 21, 2016
The best veggie pizza I have had up to date, the ingredients were so fresh! A nice quaint place, they take cash only btw.
Barb LeungJune 24, 2017
Cash only. Affordable and tasty pies; spring for the white pizza and add spinach.
Sarah AtwoodDecember 8, 2015
The regular pizza is amazing!!! It says it feeds 1-2 but could easily feed 3-4 people.
Natalie AJuly 31, 2016
Regular pie with extra basil. Perfectly crispy pizza. After 11:30 take out only.
JPOctober 26, 2015
Best New York pizza without the line. Skip going to Brooklyn and come to this location for the same authentic pizza
Michelle WilesApril 19, 2016
Cash only. Small is definitely big enough for two
Amy JOctober 25, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Great pizza! Please note: cash only, no slices, no delivery, and oddly no strollers. Last seating is at 945pm ... Yummy! Enjoy!!
Corinne KwanMarch 11, 2015
Remember to bring $$, as it's cash only! Can't go wrong with the traditional Margherita Pizza
HectorJuly 31, 2016
Original pie, get the large one, ask for extra basil. Last hour of the night is takeout only.
Ben EllisJuly 17, 2015
The food here is amazing, and the decor is nice and quaint. However, after being called a "maricone" ("faggot" in Spanish) by staff, I guess I wouldn't recommend this place - unless you're straight.
Scott CorlissApril 19, 2018
No slices, just whole pies and cash only, but worth it.
KEOctober 29, 2016
Cash only, you can only order whole pizzas. Narrow outdoor area - try to sit inside. Pizza is amazing. Interior stark and not anything to write home about.
macfixerMarch 13, 2017
Bring cash. There is a sketchy looking ATM in here, but there's probably a fee or two involved.
Anthony BraddyAugust 18, 2014
Second of three #LastSupper ingredients...the plan is to eat myself into a coma and get back to the business of the business in the AM...
Jesse GuilloryApril 14, 2012
They now have a way in from the street, much easier to find. All the pizza, none of the lines of BK, I'll take it
AdiApril 29, 2016
Pizza! They let you do half and half
jasmine sNovember 13, 2012
best pizza i've ever had and literally a hidden gem :) tucked in the corner of the church/what used to be avalon nightclub!
Harumi UNovember 12, 2015
Thin crust pizza done right. Sauce uses fresh tomatoes. Clean bathroom and swift service
alanur arasOctober 17, 2013
İts good But The ones who say best pizza in the world come to İstanbul eat pizza in a luxary rest or cafe you will find more options and and its not worse than this..I think so exagrated sorry guys
Michael JaccarinoDecember 18, 2013
Go off the usual list of pizzas and ask staff what they like - you won't be disappointed
Doris HuJune 2, 2015
Favorite pizza place! My choice of toppings: sausage, mushroom, and pepperoni
Richard DinhOctober 5, 2014
You can do half white, half red pizza in case you can't decide.
Milenna GonzalezMay 20, 2015
Quality ingredients but the pizza is too dry. And if you want to order halfs of different flavors, they charge the same if the topping is for the whole pizza. Cash only. Service not that good.
Jessica StempelApril 15, 2011
This must still be unknown to many. It's grimaldis but there's no line! Delicious amazing and cash only
Loku NYCJune 20, 2012
The fresh mozzarella cheese really makes the pizza! For more info: http://bit.ly/LdT9i3
Lesley ForresterDecember 19, 2011
Been here 5+ times
No slices. Take a whole pie to go! Pepperoni and basil is awesome! Cash only.
Milenna GonzalezMay 20, 2015
Quality ingredients, but the pizza is very dry. Service not so good. No wine nor beer, just soda. They charge the same price for toppings in half a pizza or in the whole pizza. Cash only.
Wesley CheungMarch 17, 2012
Olives are salty ! Good for about 2 slices and it gets to be too salty. Get it on half a pie if ur sharing. Good tho just not on whole pie.
Elizabeth BursteinJune 20, 2018
Brady ordered off uber eats. Great margarita and pepperoni
Katie FlynnJanuary 5, 2012
Not quite on par with the original in Brooklyn, but definitely the best pizza in the nabe!
Yaroslav PatrikeevSeptember 11, 2014
Nearly the best pizza I ever had. Strongly recommend.
Albert WengerDecember 28, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Pizza. Pizza. Pizza. The best. Sadly no liquor license. Also: cash only!
DJ GreenbergApril 28, 2012
Get a small pizza for two - its a full meal. It is epic awesome!
Katerina AnnaDecember 8, 2014
Miserable environment, mediocre pizza. If you insist eating here that's the size of a slice (pictured) so think twice before ordering the large size
CardConnect MSPAugust 4, 2013
Great pizza, but not much space to enjoy it. Also cash only :(
Ryan WurtzJuly 16, 2013
Been here 50+ times
The right unisex restroom is larger and nicer than the one on the left.
Ricky KimJanuary 6, 2017
White pizza with sausage and mushrooms. No questions!!!!!
Sebastian VillalobosDecember 21, 2013
Great pizza. Need to watch. Not to burn the borders. Urge to improve service!
Leigh FerreiraFebruary 13, 2011
cash only. i like the pure cheese/red sauce pizza (sometimes w/ pesto too). yum!
Jesse GuilloryDecember 12, 2011
Tough to find but worth it. Enter through lime light inside the church.

1 2

369 Photos

Grimaldi's

Related Searches

Other places inside Limelight Shops

You might also like

Places people like to go after Grimaldi's

Appears on 501 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.