Brother Jimmy's BBQ
(Now Closed)BBQ Joint and Sports Bar$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
94 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
AngelicaDecember 28, 2015Wings are simply the best in NYC. Good quality chicken, rub flavor is perfection and not over saucy and the blue cheese dip is chunky the only place I have ever been to get both good wings and sauce.
Lisa FinnOctober 26, 2015Skip the food and go straight for the Swamp Water cocktail served up with ten straws in a literal fishbowl, then drunkenly fight your friends over who gets to keep the toy alligator that comes on top.
The Corcoran GroupFebruary 25, 2011The original! Unwind and get crazy with some friends and their famous SWAMP WATER. Wednesday’s are southern appreciation nights, show your ID for specials.
Ali AndersonJanuary 2, 2015fishbowls, pulled pork, and PBR. Guaranteed for a fun night watching sports.
SetonMarch 19, 2015You can't go wrong with brother jimmys, but this one had very limited space. The rest of my experience was good as usual though.
Justin LukJune 7, 2010All you can eat and drink (ribs and draft beer) for $23. So good. 2 hour time limit. Bit of a downer, but adds a bit of excitement, right? Well worth the money. Great ribs.
Elisabeth SandovalJuly 27, 2013Love this place! Came here all the time. Great staff. Fun people. Def an upper east side gem.
Ellie RJanuary 1, 2015Food is actually quite solid. Consistently enjoy myself when here for drinks. Good pub/drinks/comfort food option.
Kate LJuly 10, 2013Great bluegrass/country cover band here on Tuesday nights. Fun band members and they take requests.
Raja HMay 2, 2014(As of May 2014) $16 for all you can eat hot wings and rib tips w/ crappy beer for two hours
Deborah JoyceNovember 3, 2012The menu today was SEVERELY limited (no ribs, only brisket and chicken) and they don't tell you until after you've sat there for 20 mins & ordered drinks. We paid for our drinks & left.
Gilt CityJanuary 24, 2011All of Brother Jimmy’s barbecued items are smoked for up to twelve hours using hickory wood. The result: a taste that’s distinctly Southern.
Order some 'Que, drink some Bud Light pitchers, pound some swamp water (keep the gator), stumble home and...repeat.
Lucia PalmieriAugust 2, 2014Horrible. I got delivery and the north ribs were reminiscent of a Chinese buffet. I asked for extra pickles and no gravy on the potatoes, they didn't do either. The Mac and cheese was crap. YUCK!
Charles EdgeJanuary 14, 2012Pulled pork sandwich. Don't spoil it by adding or removing anything. It's awesome!
came in for a "to-go" order and ordered a sweet tea to go with it.. they gave me a sweet tea while I waited and charged me twice. Once for the one at the table, and once for the to-go. Boo much? I lov
Donald RauscherAugust 6, 2010Last summer, had all you can eat wings and all you can drink pitchers for $15 on Mondays! Not sure if they still have it.
New Era Pinstripe BowlDecember 7, 2011$2 Bud/Bud Light Drafts, $3 House drinks & $10 Swamp Waters during Pinstripe Bowl Week, Dec. 26-30
Nikki VargasSeptember 25, 2011Unlimited wings and pitchers on Monday for $15-$20 for 2 hours makes for a nice remedy to a Monday.
The pigs pick is so bomb diggity, and the hostess is always hot.
Patrick HealyJuly 17, 2011People, do yourselves a service and go get some real BBQ - not here. Really. I think Jimmy is from Long Island.
Ask for the manager Mikey DQ and challenge him to a 1 on 1 lacrosse game.
TMO Loves FootballMarch 18, 2012Brad Esarey is the mayor of this place. He doesn't have Foursquare, but he knows everyone! Keep your eyes open
Sundays - unlimited ribs and beer. End your week correctly!
296 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Put some South in yo' mouth!
(212) 288-0999
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 6.1
"Solid quick lunch spot, sandwiches were what I expected, delicious bread too"
Tone Repollet - 6.3
"BBQ is great, and everything is super clean. The bibim naengmun and mul naengmun (which are available in the summer only) are refreshing and delicious."
Jonathan L - 8.2
"An UES outpost of the mini chain BBQ spot. Solid BBQ"
Ryan Gallagher
Places people like to go after Brother Jimmy's BBQ
- 7.0
"Great bar, went for a bday in the private room, great service, strong drinks!"
Fanny G - 6.0
"Great burgers, fun staff! ;)"
Jacqui Lisa - 5.8
"Newly renovated, LIVE bands during the week, karaoke at the bar every day, Live DJ Karaoke Thursday-Saturday nights. Great pleace to watch sporting events too! Exclusive Kiddie Karaoke Parties."
Kathy O'Shea
Appears on 207 lists
Best Barbeque In New York City
Created by The Corcoran Group
21 items • 179 followers
Created by SMKN 5 Pandeglang
40 items • 300 followers
