See all
331 photos

Rosie O'Grady's

Steakhouse, Seafood Restaurant, and Bar$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Rosie O'Grady's

5.9^/10

435

ratings

"Try their Shepherds Pie, it is excellent."(4 Tips)
"Can't go wrong with the French Onion Soup, though!"(6 Tips)
"Lobster Ravioli and the Fisherman's Plate can be highly recommended."(2 Tips)
"Filet Mignon is amazing"(3 Tips)

86 Tips and reviews

Filter:

shepherd's pie
good for groups
filet mignon
live music
risotto
bar
restaurants
creamed spinach
potatoes
casual
strawberry cake
carrot cake
good for dates
grilled sandwiches
dinner
asparagus
lunch
brunch food
pricey
lime
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

DoubleDeuceDecember 3, 2016
I had this giant burger (almost swallows the knife in it) and it was delicious. Lots of space here so my tourist guests were comfortable.
Harumi UJune 9, 2015
Grill that also serves (Irish) bar type of food. Like many restaurants in this area, they have pre theater prix fixe menu
Elly ListerApril 28, 2014
Excellent service at the bar. The signature martini was delicious. They understood we had a show to attend and made sure we made it on time.
Bev WrightJanuary 12, 2022
Norwegian Salmon and Shrimp and Scallops with Risotto were plentiful tasty, and fresh. Service was quick, cheerful, and professional.
Andrew CApril 18, 2018
Like any American restaurant with standard food and drink options... draft beer was great and french onion soup was on point + I ordered a cheeseburger medium but was cooked almost well done :(
kerstin stoepselJanuary 30, 2015
Lobster Ravioli and the Fisherman's Plate can be highly recommended. Delicious. Very good, friendly and quick service, too.
Larry EderNovember 6, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Rosies' has the best bartenders in Manhattan. Great food in the restaurant and around NYC Marathon time, it is hangout for running geeks.
Marc PhillipsNovember 23, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Great place to meet coworkers for drinks downstairs. Reasonable space for midtown.
Tiffany MartinezJune 13, 2013
I liked it! NYC is pricey but the best city in the world if u want mc Donald's go there for the dollar menu u cheap fucks.... Classy isn't cheap
Lydia VanWormerFebruary 13, 2017
Fantastic service!! Best club soda ever with muddled lime!!! 👌🏻
BradApril 22, 2014
Food is really good but expensive. Restaurant gets very busy and service becomes very slow. Great atmosphere. Don't be in a hurry I'd you going here.
Jim HudsonAugust 20, 2012
Not sure why people say bad things about the food here. Steak is amazing! Love the creamed spinach!
Rose D.October 16, 2011
Excellent 12oz filet mignon and I chose a baked potato- which was amazing. Chocolate strawberry cake is delicious!!
Greg FullerFebruary 2, 2018
Nice restaurant with decent food. Our server wasn’t very good but if I’m back in mid-town Manhattan again would try again.
Whitney RoweApril 14, 2015
Amazing burgers. Try the California burger.
Toby Sheldon-AllisonMarch 27, 2014
Filet Au poivre was incredible and so were the mussels!
Biz TraveldudeDecember 8, 2017
Nice restaurant upstairs and bar downstairs
Martin WilliamsAugust 3, 2014
They sell Shock Top (a Belgium Beer) and have live music.
Sergio MartinezNovember 27, 2013
I did love the Swordfish club sandwich! It's exquisite.
Sandy GFebruary 15, 2014
The bread is stale, the Coke is watered down, and the steak is just OK. Can't go wrong with the French Onion Soup, though!
Mike BarkerFebruary 18, 2015
Great food and very authentic. Expensive but worth it.
Johanna LynnMarch 10, 2012
Get the amazing mashed potatoes. Also restaurant prices and bar prices differ.
Yagiz AtagecFebruary 21, 2014
Food is good. Serving is magnificant. Taha was amazing.
Michael TerryJune 11, 2013
A lot of us have left bad reviews of this place. While not fabulous, it's not as terrible as some make it seem. The chicken parm was good, the French Onion soup good. Overpriced but not for NYC
Theodore KimNovember 1, 2014
Fine food, but the service has consistently been on the slow side for me. Give yourself an extra 30m if you eat here.
Alex FishMarch 3, 2015
Been here 25+ times
Johnny downstairs will always take care of you
Aimee AimeeJuly 5, 2014
The shepherd's pie is excellent.
Cori SchwabeJuly 11, 2011
The filet with roasted potatoes is to die for!! Absolutely amazing!!
Mike DNovember 12, 2013
Apparently you turn invisible to bartenders when you walk in the door. No other way to explain the complete lack of service when I sat at an uncrowned bar to eat dinner. Go elsewhere.
Ki ChoiDecember 26, 2014
Can't speak for the food but the downstairs bar is rather mediocre and can get rather rowdy on weekends.
NinjaJomAugust 25, 2013
Very delicious! Reasonably priced!
Sami HurmeJuly 24, 2013
Do not eat there! First time ever I had to send filet mignon back because it was all burned. The second one was the worst piece of meat I've ever had. Waiter tried to fix kitchen problems though.
Chris CorteseSeptember 26, 2011
Try their Shepherds Pie, it is excellent.
Ryan PetrickJune 7, 2012
Try the French onion soup! It is delicious.
Matt CorbettDecember 19, 2014
Delicious shepherds pie!!
A. Del SoleJune 18, 2012
Pleasantly surprised with my scallops. Very good.
Cristina de AtelaMay 2, 2017
Loved the onion soup! ♥️
Andy RobinsonJune 1, 2013
Shepards pie was amazing
Kimberly SalvesenFebruary 28, 2014
I would definitely recommend this bar
Patricia Elizabeth Davalos SamaniegoFebruary 3, 2015
Martini Frutal!
Wade BurrisMay 30, 2013
Came here three seperate times since it was so close to hotel and never very busy. Pretty poor service each time. Food is okay.
Natalie VAugust 8, 2016
Came here for drinks and it was a little overpriced
MathieuJanuary 24, 2018
Been here 5+ times
Good for a beer
eric bornemannApril 2, 2021
Good for a martini and that’s about it.
Steven DrankwalterNovember 24, 2019
Tourist trap, i ordered a chicken dish and im not sure what i received. Bar is nice, have a drink eat somewhere else
Wanda LarsonMarch 22, 2013
Mmmmm...perfectly done asparagus...yummy!
Mariana MoreiraFebruary 15, 2019
Been here 5+ times
French onion soup
john kellyAugust 3, 2013
Very very good Guinness!
David A. ChapaJanuary 19, 2011
The service was poor, the food (entree) unfortunately not stellar and the wines by the glass were very low end. BUT the rolls and the chicken vegetable soup was good.
Christine StoneJanuary 14, 2012
2pm on Sat is a perfect time to have a Guinness and get warm!

1 2

331 Photos

Rosie O'Grady's

Related Searches

Places inside Rosie O'Grady's

You might also like

Places people like to go after Rosie O'Grady's

Appears on 44 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.