See all
566 photos

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

(Now Closed)

BBQ Joint and Bar$$$$

Chelsea, New York

Save

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

116 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

The Corcoran GroupJuly 2, 2013
Frickles all the way! Pair them with the buffalo fried chicken sandwich before heading to an event at Madison Square Garden next door.
Lucy MariaDecember 16, 2016
The swamp water and margaritas are awesome! Loved the humongous nachos, frickles and loaded fries! Friendly service and a great after work spot or place to go with a group.
Pablo HernandezOctober 20, 2012
French fries are amazing! I think they are hand cut. The Press'd BBQ Brisket sandwich is heaven on Earth. Onion straws, gouda, pressed Texas toast and delicious and tender pork brisket. So good...
Aimée Jane ParrSeptember 23, 2018
Probably the most ‘loaded’ loaded nachos I have ever seen. If you love BBQ you will love the menu here! Pig out!
Raj S.May 4, 2012
Their pulled pork is decent. I love their Chipotle BBQ sauce though; makes the pork much better. Seating upstairs is much less crowded. For whatever reason they love the ACC, but don't love the Terps.
Stephanie P.July 21, 2013
The BBQ here is decent considering it's a chain restaurant. Their cocktails are VERY strong - hit or miss depending on the bartender. Fun place overall for a large group of people to eat or catch up.
Karen GillFebruary 3, 2016
Had lunch before a train. Pulled chicken sandwich was good and the mac and cheese was delicious! I would go there again!
Social News NetworkMarch 31, 2013
Drinks are reasonably priced and the wings are great. Come on Saturdays though, their 50 cent wings are a great deal.
WyngspanJanuary 16, 2014
We hear this is a great place to grab a drink and pulled pork sandwich before heading over to The Garden! Did you enjoy your visit? Let people know on Wyngspan! Read more
Tinashe DhliwayoFebruary 16, 2014
They don't serve the veggie burgers advertised outside and I'd recommend skipping this place altogether. Ate the fries, okra, and green beans and spent the entirety of the next day in the bathroom.
Gray Line New YorkNovember 22, 2011
Visiting from the South? Hop-off and try their North Carolina style, slow smokin' barbeque. The Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich might just change your life.
Affinia Hotel CollectionJune 13, 2014
Join the party at Brother Jimmy’s, where students cheer for their home teams, gobble down barbecue, and throw back shots until the early morning hours.
Erica♡March 10, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Their hot wings are DELICIOUS and so is the mac and cheese. . Yummy
Jason KonenAugust 7, 2014
Great pulled pork. The chipotle bbq sauce is fantastic
Veronica BenavidesAugust 16, 2014
The baby back ribs are to die for. Great cornbread.
Dana MeyersFebruary 2, 2010
If they aren't busy and you're pressed for time before you catch your train or bus, they're very accommodating in getting you in and out as quickly as possible. Incredibly friendly waitstaff!
Nikki JeanNovember 20, 2011
The mac and cheese is like easy mac. Not so good. My pulled park had lots o' fat...not nasty. I ordered yams...big mistake! My drinks were good though, my buzz is going strong!
Jamin GhaziMay 17, 2014
Swamp water (fishbowl) is a must.
BlackBook MagazineDecember 4, 2012
JEREMY WOODARD: "I used to work here, so I will always love Brother Jimmy's. I go there every Tuesday; they're really good to us." Read more
Jose NaninNovember 18, 2016
Catfish, fried okra, brisket... all delicious!
N.M. MasciaOctober 6, 2012
Don't even listen to that guy santaganti because I tasted the cornbread and its f**kin great!
Ronnie RothSeptember 8, 2015
There drinks are a bit pricy but the BBQ is excellent!
Deep GujralJanuary 17, 2016
Food is just ok. But this is a good place to go 1) If you are with a large group 2) Before an event at Madison square garden
Laverne G. - @lgestatesJune 3, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Can't Miss Monday's All You Can Eat Rib Tips, Wings & Beer!!! Salut!!!
Aimee ElizabethhSeptember 20, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Thursday is ladies night and a lot of fun! The bartenders are awesome and the frickles are amazing!
Sarah GuadalupeMay 17, 2012
Their Charlotte Tea is great and the brisket is sooooo delicious!
Martin SabinoJune 20, 2011
Been here 5+ times
rib tips are always great here but you HAVE to try the coconut margarita!
Amanda TrexlerJuly 23, 2012
Mac & cheese as a side is a MUST! Also, the raspberry margaritas are DELICIOUS!!
Gradie OakesFebruary 17, 2012
Right around the corner from the stadium, grab a Swamp Water and cheer on the Knicks. Good ribs and lots of TVs. #Linsanity.
Chris HansenMarch 17, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Get the lunch special, dry rub/mac n cheese/collard greens and the brunswick stew. You won't be hungry for a week!!
AadityaMay 15, 2017
The sloppy Joe + Slaw + (Legit) iced tea. Good stuff! Slow service though.
WillMcDMay 16, 2011
The ribs are really good. but get the sample platter and split Read more
Brian McGNovember 6, 2014
Currently serving $1 budweisers & $3 shots of jack daniel's as a limited time special
Kathy BonvillainJuly 7, 2012
Try an Abita Amber or Abita Turbodog. Excellent Louisiana beer!
Joanne HaasAugust 31, 2013
Try the Carolina Tea - Strong, but good
John JohnsonApril 5, 2014
The fried Brussel sprouts are awesome.
Conrad Greiner-BechertJanuary 30, 2018
Neither impressed with the food nor with the beer selection.
Erica VirtueJanuary 5, 2014
Don't expect authentic tasting Carolina style BBQ. It's prepackaged and bland. Also, I found a giant piece if plastic in my sandwich. Gross.
Ben GaspariniNovember 12, 2016
This location gets over crowded with tourists and MSG peeps.
Preston Roberts Jr.April 26, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Good place for a bar that's across the street from MSG.
KarenOctober 23, 2018
To the owner/manager: The rude hostesses at the front need to be fired. They aren't helping you get business.
Celenise MahmoodOctober 26, 2014
Drinks and mac and cheese are delicious!
Anthony RalloFebruary 18, 2013
Kids eat free at lunch with an adult order.
Jan SpoorenbergSeptember 20, 2014
great place to go for drinks and food
Ailie ChangMay 15, 2017
Their sweet tea is legit!
Mark GordonNovember 2, 2010
On mondays all you can eat wings/rib tips and all you can drink beer for less thqn 20 bucks? Awesome.
AKWMay 22, 2012
This place is just ok for the most part. The food is not bad or great it is just ok. Quiet place to go during lunch time
Nakia HApril 14, 2010
Shock Top beer was tasty, like Blue Moon. They have Abita from New Orleans which I love. Go Tar Heels!
Julian QuiterioMarch 12, 2012
Not a large menu, full bar, but very good burgers.
Jeffrey JohnsonFebruary 2, 2011
Wednesday night is Southern Appreciation night - 25% off food with Southern ID! #food

1 2 3

566 Photos

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Appears on 128 lists

More from Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Is this your business? Claim it now.