Old Mill Inn

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Mattituck

Save

Old Mill Inn

9 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Eric ChristOctober 27, 2013
Place was amazing! Chili mussels, oysters, raw tuna burger, fish and chips! Quite and amazing lunch! Service was awesome! Make it a point to stop in and have lunch and drinks!
NewsdayJune 4, 2014
Try the hopping-fresh local striped bass or pan-seared Scottish salmon. The roast chicken and fried calamari are just about perfect. Read more
Kaely GSeptember 3, 2015
Okay appetizers, really good salmon, amazing house-made desserts (get the beignets!). Great outdoor seating.
Alexandre Favreau-LessardAugust 7, 2014
Make sure to have dinner on the back terrace, awesome sunset views!!
The Corcoran GroupMay 16, 2011
Open Friday through Sunday for Lunch & Dinner. Delicious seasonal menu – get a plate of local Oysters, Peel-n-Eat Shrimp and the Monkfish.
Vishal GuptaJuly 27, 2012
Great seafood joint. Stay for the view of the water.
Angela RJuly 21, 2013
The Lobster Roll is as good as the Cape! View lovely!
Vanessa JupeMay 28, 2012
Amazing spicy mussels! Get them!
Simply ElegantOctober 16, 2011
Mussels and calamari ate amazing

32 Photos

Kev & Ang's North Fork Wedding Weekend
Created by Kevin Skobac
46 items • 4 followers
Out of town
Created by Amie G
2 items
NoFo
Created by Jill G
133 items • 18 followers

United States » New York » Suffolk County » Mattituck »

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.