See all
617 photos

Gotham Bar and Grill

(Now Closed)

New American Restaurant$$$$

Greenwich Village, New York

Save

Has a stamp of approval from The New York Times and Food Network

219 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Daniel BouludJuly 30, 2014
The perfect place to go veg… particularly during the bountiful summer months! Chef Portale does a wonderful job of highlighting produce from the Union Square Greenmarket.
Serious EatsSeptember 17, 2014
French pastry doesn't get better than this, try the Tarte Tatin for two. The best flaky pie crust of your life brushed with a burnished coat of glazed puff pastry, & inside the soft baked apples glow. Read more
EaterApril 18, 2017
Chef Raprocki bakes each tart to order, resulting in densely caramelized apples inside a buttery, flaky crust. Served alongside vanilla ice cream, it’s a fine way to finish a meal at Gotham. Read more
TaniaApril 20, 2018
I tried kale strawberry salad, branzino and lemon parfait from the prix fix menu and everything was delicious, thus cappuccino was too strong like real espresso.. delicious food! Portions are ok!
ReserveJanuary 28, 2016
Located on a tree-lined Greenwich Village street, Gotham Bar and Grill captures the cozy feel of a Parisian brasserie in a chic, downtown setting. Read more
Nate BeattyMarch 8, 2016
One of the best meals I have had in my life. The atmosphere is what makes this place. It's nice, and knows it, but stands behind its food rather than glaming you into thinking you've got a good meal.
Nathalie De ClercqNovember 19, 2014
Book in advance and ask to be placed on one of the tables on the platform. That's where the regulars go - and for good reason. Lobster is wonderful and the steak is perfect. Do both!
Tim SheaJanuary 19, 2016
The drinks are amazing! The staff is amazing! And although you might be tempted to think you can get a steak anywhere, GET IT HERE!
LilyDecember 9, 2019
NYT Critic's Pick *** (11/2019): "Crab galette (bar menu); Vic’s burger (bar menu); Baywater Sweet oysters; tilefish; spaghetti neri; braised rabbit; lamb shoulder; pain perdu; soufflé; tarte Tatin."
New York PostSeptember 21, 2014
The chef's fabled reliance on the Union Square Greenmarket can be limiting, and menu seems frozen in 1990s. Where are the grains, legumes and accents from beyond our nearby farms? ★★★ Read more
Wise YoungApril 27, 2014
Had dinner and now movie next door. My favorite dish there is the skate. This time, I got the Naiman pork chop. Perfectly cooked, tender, pepper crust, baby daikon, spinach, and a glass of wine.
JessicaAugust 6, 2015
Love! Especially during Restaurant week, it was a great opportunity to try the resto at an affordable price. Definitely one of the best places I've been at in NYC so far!
Tendai Dephine NdoroMarch 16, 2017
Wow the food was amazing and tasty. Loved the Shrimp cocktail. Also love the Blackened Cod with lemograss & Ginger sauce First place where they get the beer shanty right!
EaterJuly 22, 2016
A lot of restaurants now serve tuna tartare towers like Gotham Bar and Grill, but the original is still the best. Read more
Peter ForemanSeptember 11, 2013
Outstanding. I had dinner, it was so good I went back two days later for lunch. The corn soup on lunch menu & cod on dinner menu are great. Chocolate cake is to die for.
Caroline DengFebruary 4, 2016
Went here for NYC's Restaurant Week. Didn't think there was anything exceptional about Gotham especially considering its price, but its assorted sorbets and signature Gotham cake save it.
Ryan RossAugust 6, 2014
The service here is amongst the best I've had anywhere in the world. The food is great and the cocktails lovely. It's pricey but it's an experience worth shelling out for if you can.
jansen cOctober 20, 2017
Awesome place to bring your date, the lobster is really amazing plus wonderful service and knowledgeable waiter/waitress
Harumi UJuly 30, 2014
In this city, their longevity must mean something. Whichever the dish you choose you will be happy with it so all you need to worry is what ingredient you want to eat today
Noah SellingDecember 9, 2015
Sit up top for an amazing experience and if you have an anniversary, call in advance as they do it right.
Sacha SJuly 5, 2017
Very American fine dining. If you're dating someone with money go here😂. It is fun. The food is gooooood and the service is amazing. It is a New York institution.
NY WaterwayAugust 2, 2012
The Sweet chilled pea soup, Pan seared salmon, Grill Hanger Steak, Creme Fraiche Panna Cotta, Chocolate cake are ALL a must get if you want a delicious dining experience in Manhattan.
Hien LyJanuary 14, 2016
Tuna tartare, seafood salad and the seared fois gras are amazing. Oh, that seared fois gras!Cauliflower was forgettable. Rack of lamb and pork chop were fine but didn't blow us away.
林林August 30, 2017
Been here 4 years ago and All the food was superb (Tuna Tartar, Duck Confit). Recommended:-)
ToshieAugust 27, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The more I go, the more I like it. The service is superb and the food+drinks are just perfect! Don't forget to order the scallops, they are simply amazing.
MarcOctober 11, 2019
GrubHub - NYC ExcitingNew Brgs Sept'19: Vic's Brgr - resurrected 1of NY's most famous chef burgers — aged beef, bone marrow, mango BBQ sauce, and frizzled shallots
Valerie SecklerJanuary 3, 2012
Greats can come-and-go in a flash, but Gotham lives on first-class food+drinks. A splendid vodka gimlet was paired with mixed nuts, a rarity at the bar in 2011. Decor has gone stuffy, crowd classic.
Alice EunjinApril 28, 2015
wild striped bass ceviche with the Gotham Burger or a roasted beet salad, with the spendiest options being a pan-seared halibut or beef short ribs.
Lori LuoAugust 10, 2014
One of the forefront market-driven restaurants, Gotham continues to offer an excellent lunch prix-fixe, which includes their signature Chocolate Cake.
CharlottesNovember 11, 2016
The prix fixe lunch is a dream at just $38. Quality food in OTT olde world setting. Service is rather 'relaxed' but you get what you pay for right? No complaints!
Michael Fox-RabinovitzApril 3, 2015
Great cocktails, superb service and mouth watering dishes, really an all around fantastic place. Good for a business dinner or for a third date.
Matt NeemsNovember 18, 2016
A bit of a stuffy 'old boys club' vibe, but the food here is phenomenal and will not disappoint. The special, truffle risotto with farm fresh egg was ridiculous.
Gilbert WongJuly 29, 2016
Been here 5+ times
We always enjoy sitting at the bar, their food and drinks always delicious. This kind of place is slowly disappearing! Has class and charm!!
Douglas EllimanJuly 24, 2014
Great for an upscale night out, with an innovative and tasty menu! We found the service to be exquisite. Definitely try the hanger steak.
Daniel BrownDecember 16, 2015
Incredible food, good lively atmosphere, not too stuffy. A more 'senior' crowd, but probably because they keep coming back. Definitely visit
Wei VaynNovember 11, 2013
Try the Atlantic Halibut - Bouillabaisse style. sweet shrimp, razor clams, mussels, braised fennel and marble potatoes and saffron shellfish broth. It tasted very Asian.
Pete SaverinoAugust 13, 2019
Been here 50+ times
All the bartenders here are top notch! But, by far, Billy and Mark are a slice of old New York fine bartending!
Christine GFebruary 20, 2013
Fantastic service. Tuna tartare & scallops for first and second courses. Lamb and duck for entrees, and and with the flour less chocolate cake. Great meal.
Serious EatsNovember 15, 2013
One of our favorite classic fine dining spots with a good lunch deal and excellent desserts.
Eric TashJune 24, 2014
Came here last night to celebrate wife's bday. Any resto of this caliber sets personal expectations high. Food was superb & service was excellent too. Only issue was seating.
Rommy NalonNovember 29, 2014
Best tuna tartare and seafood salad I ever had! The food is amazing and the staff incredibly professional. Excellent wine list is a plus.
ReserveFebruary 10, 2016
The Gotham Chocolate Cake is rich, chocolatey goodness served warm with salted almond ice cream. Read more
New York PostSeptember 25, 2014
Try the roasted portobello mushrooms, with the company of eggplant, chanterelles and corn-eggplant succotash. Read more
Martha FelixAugust 4, 2015
No question go for the Prix Fixe. The duck is great. Pair with their Santenay Bourgogne
Michelin Travel & LifestyleDecember 2, 2013
The classics never falter, from striped bass ceviche & smoked salmon galette to excellent burgers & chocolate cake. – Green Guide Editor
Odile RoujolNovember 5, 2016
Great place, enjoy the lobster and try the chocolate cake as a dessert !
Julia MAugust 20, 2014
Black Cod, the halibut, soft shell crab, and of course, the Gotham chocolate cake served with salted almond ice cream. Yum.
Theresa GFebruary 20, 2013
go for the $33 greenmarket prix fixe 3 course lunch and pair it with a $9 glass of sauvignon blanc - amazing deal and excellent choices!
Ingvild M. PlosivDecember 3, 2014
Great miso marinate cod, and the steak was also amazing according to my boyfriend. Quite expensive (especially the wines).
Lihle Z MtshaliNovember 18, 2010
I forgot to check in when I was there this afternoon, but loved this place. It is classy with great service. The food is outstanding. A simple green salad is so well made. Try the organic chicken, too

1 2 3 4 5

617 Photos

Gotham Bar and Grill

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Gotham Bar and Grill

Appears on 1,038 lists

Top places in the area