Trading Post
(Now Closed)American Restaurant, Bar, and Whisky Bar$$$$
Financial District, New York
87 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Roger MitchellAugust 17, 2013Love this place. Service is excellent, food always superb. Been here for brunch & dinner, atmosphere is intimate yet metropolitan, good for foodies, first dates, and launch pad for excursion weekends
Dave YoungAugust 24, 2013The seafood sharing platter is perfect for 3! And a steal IMO. The skirt steak perfectly rare and chimichurri to die for. The bartender in the whiskey den so knowledgeable and easy to talk to
LTAugust 25, 2013Genuinely friendly staff. Get the seafood deck. Though the price may seem intimidating, it's a great deal considering the generous portions of seafood you get. Great wine list too.
SiobhánJune 23, 2018Came for a group lunch. Food was great though definitely seafood heavy which wasn't my forte. Highly recommend getting a bunch of things to share and drinks as your best course of action.
Aniruddha MandkeMay 17, 2015Unassuming and welcoming place. Warm and thoughtful staff. Excellent food - do try Amish styled chicken, never had softer chicken. Great date spot. Also an excellent bar for casual hangout.
Jenn RrrrrrrJune 29, 2013Check out the upstairs and downstairs they did a lovely job with the decor. John the bartender is super nice be sure to strike up a conversation with him. Looking forward to returning! Xoxo
Chelsea BalkanDecember 14, 2018#FabuLIST #DubiDO good spot for large group business lunches. Easy to get a table and quiet. Food is OK. Order the brussels sprouts side to share. Pass on the Mac and cheese though. No flavor.
Brian PonceFebruary 23, 2019The oldest surviving granite Greek Revival building in NYC, former ship's chandlery. Amazing large space with intimate nooks and crannies and fabulous food.- Heather SwansonJuly 2, 2013This place is awesome! Lots of little nooks for quiet dining and a big bar for drinks after if you feel like a hang. Great food and drinks and the staff couldn't be friendlier.
Kathleen ColishNovember 2, 2013Awesome place. Staff is really friendly and helpful. The decor is beautiful, lots of cozy intimate spaces to eat and drink. Definitely go downstairs to the whiskey cellar!!
Jim ColucciJuly 17, 2013Great menu with serious, perfectly prepared food in a beautifully renovated and comfortable setting. Must try the heirloom tomato, watermelon & feta salad with balsamic drizzle!
Did you go downstairs? The Whiskey Cellar is where it's at. Four kinds of Jameson - imagine what the rest of the menu offers. Knowledgeable service and a cool place to chill.- Amazing space! Great service and the Peck Slip is by far one of the best raw towers in the area. Oh - and get the Brined chicken with truffled mash - delish!!
Brad MatthewsApril 6, 2017One of the best experiences I've had at a Manhattan bar, full stop. The host during happy hour provided a personal touch consistent with 5-star hotels.
Mandar MSeptember 5, 2014Dude!! Try the mussels pot. Probably the only place in the world that throws in spicy sausage slices in with the mussels - what a kick !
Trae FSeptember 24, 2017Stopped in for a drink at the bar. A lovely and warm place with a club like atmosphere. Impressive. I'd love to go back to eat here.
Marcela CamachoFebruary 11, 2014Loved the trading post feeling of the place. Great service. Salmon, squash and spinach entree was incredible! Im coming back as soon as i can!
Kimmie OhhJanuary 9, 2020Good spot for groups. Order app & drinks during happy hour. Enjoy the treats outside on a nice day :)
Dusan StojicevicJuly 5, 2013The Scottish salmon is amazing. They have an extensive wine list and and an impressive selection of whiskeys. Very warm and friendly staff.
Kim AbendJune 27, 2013Amazing Space. Literally has something for everyone...great food, great wine, community space or privacy, friendly staff providing great service.
LisetteMay 31, 2016Relaxed but elegant spot near the South Street Seaport. Great for lunch/dinner away from the crush of the crowd.
Avneesh KohliJanuary 28, 2018The ambience here is first class. Really enjoyed the burger and fries too.
Kristen AzevedoAugust 12, 2016Such a great place. Laid back, but classy. Great food. Try the four cheese flatbread. Delicious!
LeifJuly 19, 2016You can't go wrong with the burger. We've been at least three times and it hasn't failed us!
Melody GambinoDecember 10, 2014Great place for a large group, there are small cubby holes for tables making your dining private
Honghui YuOctober 16, 2017The mushroom and barley risotto is delicious. Other entree options pale in comparison.
Ashley VelazquezJuly 18, 2015Absolutely love this place!! Great for dates, after-hours drinks, or even investor meetings.
Grace MaJanuary 14, 2014tons of space and drinks to choose from, awesome decor, good place to host a large party in the fidi
FranSeptember 29, 2017Great date place or a casual dinner. Food was impressive and the cocktails were great!
Nidhi KayMay 5, 2019Great brunch, chef’s egg sandwich, chicken and waffles, Cinnabon, can’t go wrong!
Erin GApril 9, 2015Amazing craft cocktails. Cheese & meat plates were delicious, but a bit pricy for the size.
MunaDecember 24, 2013Kind waitstaff, delicious skirt steak, get the side of mushrooms. Nice classic American decor.
BrightyJune 12, 2016Head here if you're after an extensive whiskey selection, and not a large beer selection
Lobster Mac and cheese and half off bottles of wine on Sundays and Mondays!
Matthew RimmerOctober 12, 2013Flatbreads are the best I've ever had! Also try the Greenore single grain Irish Whisky.
Jessie ChenJanuary 19, 2015Friendly staff, good cocktails and cool atmosphere. Lobster Mac n cheese!!
Devon NagleJune 19, 2013Plan to stay awhile this place is huge with a million secret corners and a top shelf whiskey cellar
SS+K's Guide to Downtown NYApril 21, 2014This high end pub is a good choice for a sit down team or business lunch
130 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Upscale American Restaurant & Bar in South Street Seaport
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Tue
- 11:00 AM–1:00 AM
- Wed–Fri
- 11:00 AM–2:00 AM
- Sat
- Noon–2:00 AM
- Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
(646) 370-3337
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Smoking
Yes
Music
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Get the artichoke hearts, brussel sprouts & smoked mac and cheese! Entrees are big so you may want to split."
Brittany L. - 8.8
"Roasted veggies and mushrooms are so simple and delicious. Get more than you think are necessary."
Mark Himmelsbach - 9.1
"Excellent wine list. Start with a seafood tower."
James Kiernan
Places people like to go after Trading Post
- 8.8
"Omg I love this area....it has gr8 shopping spots for my fellow shopaholics summer in the area is amazing I love the markets"
Märlënë Bëltrë - 8.9
"The nighttime views of the city skyline are amazing! Watch sunsets here!"
Kimmie Ohh - 9.3
"Great place. People are all chilling having fun. Great drinks and service"
Heba Abdella
Appears on 290 lists
Created by Rana Rouhana
96 items • 14 followers
Created by Rana Rouhana
166 items • 518 followers
Created by Tom Bernard
142 items • 11 followers
